Skip to main content

Table 1 Description of Hypothesis Testing Methods and Significance Cutoffs

From: A power comparison of generalized additive models and the spatial scan statistic in a case-control setting

Hypothesis Testing Method

Abbreviation

Description

Significance Cutoff

Conditional Permutation Test

CPT

Select optimal span size for observed data by minimizing AIC statistic across range of spans. Compare difference in deviance statistic to conditional permutation distribution obtained by holding span size constant.

0.025

Fixed Span Permutation Test

FSPT

Select span size a priori. Compare difference in deviance statistic to conditional permutation distribution obtained by holding span size constant.

0.05

Fixed Multiple Span Permutation Test

FMSPT

Select 3-5 span sizes a priori. For each span size, compare the difference in deviance statistic to corresponding conditional permutation distribution obtained by holding the span size constant. Reject the null hypothesis if at least one p-value falls below the significance cutoff.

0.05 # S p a n s i z e s

Unconditional Permutation Test

UPT

Select optimal span size for observed data as in CPT. Compare difference in deviance statistic to unconditional permutation distribution obtained by selecting optimal span size for each permuted dataset.

0.05

Spatial Scan Statistic

---

Detects the most likely cluster through a likelihood ratio test comparing the likelihood of cases within to outside a circular zone of interest. P-values are obtained through Monte Carlo methods

0.05