Systematic literature review of reproductive outcome associated with residential proximity to polluted sites

Kihal-Talantikite, Wahida; Zmirou-Navier, Denis; Padilla, Cindy; Deguen, Séverine

doi:10.1186/s12942-017-0091-y

International Journal of Health Geographics

Table 3 Summary of reproductive outcomes related to the polluted sites (order by outcome)

From: Systematic literature review of reproductive outcome associated with residential proximity to polluted sites

Outcomes	Polluted site	Study design	Population study	Database study	Methods	References
Birth outcome (LBW/PTB)
LBW	Landfill	Ecologic study	All live births	National birth data-based study	Poisson regression model	Elliot et al. 2001 [45]
			All births in Scotland	National birth data-based study	Model prediction from poisson regression	Morris et al. 2003 [47]
			All births	Register of the office for national statistics	Poisson cumulative probabilities were calculated	Field et al. 2000 [21]
		Birth certificate-based study	All births	Birth certificate	Logistic regression model	Berry et al. 1997 [27]
		Case–control study	All live births to residents on Island of Montreal, 1979–1989 (excluded multiple birth and births to parous mothers)	Birth registration	Unconditional logistic regression	Goldbrg et al. 1995 [54]
		Retrospective cohort study	All singleton live births in England, 1986–1999	Office of National statistics birth recodes	Logistic regression	Morgan et al. 2004 [50]
	Dumpsite	Retrospective cohort study	All live singleton live births without congenital anomalies	Alaska Bureau of Vital statistics	Logistic regression	Gilbreath et al. 2006 [29]
	Industry	Case–control study	All births from the 1988 National Maternal and Infant Health Survey conducted in 48 states	National Maternal and Infant Health Survey (NMIHS)	Univariate and multivariate analyses	Sosniak et al. 1994 [30]
	Industry	Ecological study	All births in Teesside and Sunderland, 1986–1993	Office of population and censuses and survey	Unclear	Bhopal et al. 1999 [48]
		Ecological study	All singleton live births registred between 2004–2008	National institute for statistics	A Besag, York, and Mollié model	Castello et al. 2013 [53]
	HWS	Ecologic study	All births during 1994–2000 (excluded plural birth)	Birth certificate-based study	Multiple logistic models	Baibergenova et al. 2003 [28]
		Cohort study	All Live births and stillbirths, 1988–1998	Nova scotia atlee perinatal database	Logistic regression models	Dodds et al. 2001 [55]
	Incinerator	Retrospective cohort study	All births and fetal deaths in Japan, 1997–1998	Vital statistic records and birth certificate data	Stone’s unconditional test	Tango et al. 2004 [56]
LBW	Several site	Case–control study	All live births 1983–1985	Vital statistics files	Linear regression	Shaw et al. 1992 [23]
PTB	Landfill	Birth certificate-based study	All births	Birth certificate	Logistic regression model	Berry et al. 1997 [27]
		Case–control study	All live births to residents on Island of Montreal, 1979–1989 (excluded multiple birth and births to parous mothers)	Birth registration	Unconditional logistic regression	Goldbrg et al. 1995 [54]
	Waste	Cohort study	Live births and stillbirths, 1988–1998	Nova scotia atlee perinatal database	Logistic regression models	Dodds et al. 2001 [55]
	Dumpsite	Retrospective cohort study	All live singleton live births in Alaska Native villages without congenital anomalies	Birth records from the Alaska Bureau of Vital statistics	Logistic regression	Gilbreath et al. 2006 [29]
	Indurties	Ecologic study	All singleton live births registred between 2004–2008	National institute for statistics	A Besag, York, and Mollié model	Castello et al. 2013 [53]
SGA	Indurties	Ecologic study	All singleton live births registred between 2004–2008	National institute for statistics	A Besag, York, and Mollié model	Castello et al. 2013 [53]
SGA	Landfill	Case–control study	All live births to residents on Island of Montreal, 1979–1989 (excluded multiple birth and births to parous mothers)	Birth registration	Unconditional logistic regression	Goldbrg et al. 1995 [54]
IURG	Waste site	Cohort study	Live births and stillbirths, 1988–1998	Nova scotia atlee perinatal database	Logistic regression models	Dodds et al. 2001 [55]
IURG	Dumpsite	Retrospective cohort study	All live singleton live births in Alaska Native villages without congenital anomalies	Birth records from the Alaska Bureau of Vital statistics	Logistic regression	Gilbreath et al. 2006 [29]
Fetal /neonataldealth
Stillbirth	Incinerators	Retrospective cohort study	All live birth and stillbirth	Birth certificate (Cumbriam birth database)	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003c [44]
	Industrie	Retrospective cohort study	All live birth and stillbirth	Cohort-based study	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003b [43]
	Industrie	Ecological study	All births and stillbirths in Teesside and Sunderland, 1986–1993	Office of population and censuses and survey	Unclear	Bhopal et al. 1999 [48]
	Landfill	Ecologic study	Study of live births andstillbirths	National birth and stillbirth data	Poisson regression model	Elliott et al. 2001 [45]
			All births and stillbirths in Scotland between 1982 and 1997	National register-based study	Poisson regression model	Morris et al. 2003 [47]
		Retrospective cohort study	All live births and stillbirths	Cohort-based study	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003a [42]
Neonatal death	Incinerators	Retrospective cohort study	All live birth and stillbirth	Birth certificate (Cumbriam birth database)	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003c [44]
		Retrospective cohort study	All births and fetal deaths in Japan, 1997–1998	Vital statistic records and birth certificate data	Unconditional test	Tango et al. 2004 [56]
	Industrie	Retrospective cohort study	All live birth and stillbirth	Cohort-based study	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003b [43]
	Landfill	Retrospective cohort study	All live birth and stillbirth	Cohort-based study	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003a [42]
	Dumpsite	Retrospective cohort	All live births and fetal deaths in Alaska Native villages, 1997–2001	Birth records from the Alaska Bureau of Vital statistics	Logistic regression	Gilbreath and Kass 2006 [36]
	Crematorium	Retrospective cohort study	All live birth and stillbirth	Birth certificate (Cumbriam birth database)	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003c [44]
Infant death	Incinerators	Retrospective cohort study	All births and fetal deaths in Japan, 1997–1998	Vital statistic records and birth certificate data	Unconditional test	Tango et al. 2004 [56]
	Waste site	Case–control study	All births	National maternal and infant health survey	Univariate and multivariate analyses	Sosniak et al. 1994 [30]
Fetal death	Waste site	Case–control	All births and fetal death	Birth and death records (Washington State vital records)	Multivariable logistic regression	Mueller et al. 2007 [40]
	Dumpsite	Retrospective cohort	All live births and fetal deaths in Alaska Native villages, 1997–2001	Birth records from the Alaska Bureau of Vital statistics	Logistic regression	Gilbreath et al. 2006 [36]
All congenital anomaly combined
	Landfill	Ecologic study	Live births, stillbirths, congenital malformations including termination	Congenital register-based study	Poisson regression model	Elliott et al. 2001 [45]
	Landfill	Ecologic study	All births, stillbirths, and termination registries in Scotland between 1982 and 1997	National register-based study	Poisson regression model	Morris et al. 2003 [47]
			Live and still born babies	Register of the office for national statistics	Poisson regression	Field et al. 2000 [21]
			Live births, stillbirths and termination	National congenital anomaly register-based study	Bayesian hierarchical logistic regression	Elliott et al. 2009 [11]
			Live births, late foetal deaths and terminations	The National Down’s Syndrome Cytogenetics Register (NDSCR)	Regression modelling within a bayesian framework	Jarup et al. 2007 [49]
		Cohort study	All birth (live birth)	UK office national	Logistic regression model	Palmer et al. 2005 [46]
		Retrospective cohort study	Live births and stillbirths	Cohort	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003a [42]
		Case–control study	All live births, stillbirth, fetal deaths, and pregnancy terminations	Malformation register	Logistic regression models	Vriljheld et al. 2002a [51]
		Case–control study	Live births, stillbirths, and fetal deaths from 20 weeks gestation, and termination of pregnancy	Malformation register	Logistic regression models	Vriljheld et al. 2002b [1]
		Case–control study	All live births, stillbirth, fetal deaths, and pregnancy terminations	Malformation register	Logistic and related binomial regression models	Dolk et al. 1998 [52]
		Cohort and case–control studies		Regional congenital anomalies registry		Boyle et al. 2004 [41]
		Ecological study	All births	Danish Birth Defect Register	Risk rate calculated by dividing the sum of congenital anomalies by total birth	Kloppenborg et al. 2005 [26]
	Waste site	Case–control study	All live births, 1983–1984	Congenital malformations registry	Unconditional linear logistic regression	Geschwind et al. 1992 [37]
		Case–control study	All births and fetal deaths, 1983–1988;	Birth and fetal death certificate	Logistic regression model	Orr et al. 2002 [12]
		Case–control study	Study of births from the 1988 National Maternal and Infant Health Survey conducted in 48 states	National Maternal and Infant Health Survey	Univariate and multivariate analyses	Sosniak et al. 1994 [30]
		Case–control study	All singleton birth	The Newe York State Congenital Malformation Registry	Unconditional logistic regression	Marshall et al. 1997 [38]
			Singleton infant born alive or stillborn	California birth Defects Monitoring Program	Unconditional logistic regression	Croen et al. 1997 [35]
			All liveborn	Registry of all cases of confirmed heart disease born in Dallas County, Texas	Chi-square and mantel Haenzel analysis	Malik et al. 2004 [31]
			All live birth	Childrens’s Hospital of Wisconsin (CHW) and birth record	Logistic regression	Yauck et al. 2004 [22]
			Live births and fetal deaths	Texas Birth Defects Registry	Logistic regression	Brender et al. 2008 [33]
			Live births and fetal deaths (unless the termination had a vital record)	Texas Birth Defects Registry	Logistic regression	Brender et al. 2006 [32]
			Live births and fetal deaths of 20 weeks or greater gestation	Texas Birth Defects Registry	Logistic regression	Suarez et al. 2007 [39]
			Live births and fetal deaths	Texas Birth Defects Registry and birth or fetal death certificat	Logistic regression	Langlois et al. 2009 [13]
			Fetal deaths of ≥ 20 weeks gestation and live births,	Washington State vital record	Mantel haenzel analysis, logistic regression	Mueller et al. 2007 [40]
		Ecologic study	All live birth, stillbirths induced abortions and fetal death	Northern region Congenital Abnormality Survey (NorCAS)	Poisson regressions	Cresswel et al. 2003 [24]
		Cohort study	Live births and stillbirths, 1988–1998	Nova scotia atlee perinatal database	Logistic regression models	Dodds et al. 2001 [55]
		Descriptive geographical study	All birth defect cases and births during 1982–1989	Glasgow Register of Congenital anomalies	Poisson regressions	Eizaguirre et al. 2000 [25]
		Case–control study	All singleton infant born during 1987–2001	Birth-hospital discharge records	Multivariable logistic regression	Kuhen et al. 2007 [34]
	Industries	Ecological study	All births, stillbirths, and terminations in Teesside and Sunderland, 1986–1993	Congenital abnormalities register	Unclear	Bhopal et al. 1999 [48]
		Retrospective cohort study	All live births and stillbirths	Cohort-based study	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003b [43]
		Ecological study	All live births and stillbirths	Regional medical center	Calculation of rate	Bentov et al. 2006 [57]
		Case–control study	All singleton birth	The Newe York State Congenital Malformation Registry	Unconditional logistic regression	Marshall et al. 1997 [38]
			All live birth	Childrens’s Hospital of Wisconsin (CHW) and birth record	Logistic regression	Yauck et al. 2004 [22]
			Live births and fetal deaths	Texas Birth Defects Registry	Logistic regression	Brender et al. 2008 [33]
		Case–control study	Live births and fetal deaths	Texas Birth Defects Registry	Logistic regression	Brender et al. 2008 [33]
			Live births and fetal deaths of 20 weeks or greater gestation	Texas Birth Defects Registry	Logistic regression	Suarez et al. 2007 [39]
			Live births and fetal deaths	Texas Birth Defects Registry and birth or fetal death certificat	Logistic regression	Langlois et al. 2009 [13]
	Dumpsite	Retrospective cohort	Live births and fetal deaths in Alaska Native villages, 1997–2001	Birth records from the Alaska Bureau of Vital statistics	Poisson regression	Gilbreath et al. 2006 [36]
	Several sites	Case–control study	All live births and fetal deaths 1983–1985	California Births Defects Monitoring Program	Logistic regression	Shaw et al. 1992 [23]
	Incinerators	Retrospective cohort	All births and fetal deaths in Japan, 1997–1998	Vital statistic records and birth certificate data	Stone’s unconditional test	Tango et al. 2004 [56]
	Incinerators	Retrospective cohort study	Live births and stillbirths	Birth certificate (Cumbriam birth database)	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003 [44]
	Crematoriums	Retrospective Cohort study	Live births and stillbirths	Birth certificate (Cumbriam birth database)	Multivariate logistic regression	Dummer et al. 2003 [44]

Back to article page

ISSN: 1476-072X

Contact us

Submission enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com