- Open Access
Landscape, demographic, entomological, and climatic associations with human disease incidence of West Nile virus in the state of Iowa, USA
International Journal of Health Geographics volume 7, Article number: 19 (2008)
West Nile virus (WNV) emerged as a threat to public and veterinary health in the Midwest United States in 2001 and continues to cause significant morbidity and mortality annually. To investigate biotic and abiotic factors associated with disease incidence, cases of reported human disease caused by West Nile virus (WNV) in the state of Iowa were aggregated by census block groups in Iowa for the years 2002–2006. Spatially explicit data on landscape, demographic, and climatic conditions were collated and analyzed by census block groups. Statistical tests of differences between means and distributions of landscape, demographic, and climatic variables for census block groups with and without WNV disease incidence were carried out. Entomological data from Iowa were considered at the state level to add context to the potential ecological events taking place.
Numerous statistically significant differences were shown in the means and distributions of various landscape and demographic variables for census block groups with and without WNV disease incidence. Census block groups with WNV disease incidence had significantly lower population densities than those without. Landscape variables showing differences included stream density, road density, land cover compositions, presence of irrigation, and presence of animal feeding operations. Statistically significant differences in the annual means of precipitations, dew point, and minimum temperature for both the year of WNV disease incidence and the prior year, were detected in at least one year of the analysis for each parameter. However, the differences were not consistent between years.
The analysis of human WNV disease incidence by census block groups in Iowa demonstrated unique landscape, demographic, and climatic associations. Our results indicate that multiple ecological WNV transmission dynamics are most likely taking place in Iowa. In 2003 and 2006, drier conditions were associated with WNV disease incidence. In a significant novel finding, rural agricultural settings were shown to be strongly associated with human WNV disease incidence in Iowa.
West Nile virus was first recorded in the United States in 1999 and quickly spread across the country with 27,396 reported cases of WNV disease and 1025 fatalities through 2007 . Some of the highest rates of WNV disease in the USA have occurred in the northern Midwest and plains states . From 2002–2007, 23.6% of total WNV disease incidence occurred in Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, South Dakota, and North Dakota , while these states contain approximately 3.8% of the population of the continental USA. The disproportionate incidence in this area merits investigation distinct from the number of WNV related studies published about other areas of the country such as more densely populated Eastern states [2–6] and urban areas like Chicago and New York [7–9]. Few studies have described WNV landscape ecology/spatial epidemiology in northern Midwest and plains states [10, 11].
West Nile virus is a vector-borne disease that is maintained in an enzootic cycle, transmitted primarily between avian hosts and mosquito vectors . The spread and establishment of the virus throughout North America has been attributed to the large number of mosquito species that can be infected with the virus . A number of mosquitoes have tested positive for the presence of WNV infection, but select Culex species are considered the most important vectors because of their inherent susceptibility that facilitates amplification and transmission of the virus. Culex. pipiens L. and Cx. restuans Theobald are thought to be the primary vectors in the north-eastern and north-central United States while Cx. tarsalis and Cx. quinquefasciatus are the primary vectors in much of the western United States . As WNV moved westward in 2001–2004, the proportion of Cx. tarsalis positive mosquito pools out of total positive pools became much greater . Culex pipiens, Cx. restuans, and Cx. tarsalis mosquitoes are all present in Iowa, but differ in habitat requirements. Culex pipiens is considered an urban and suburban mosquito species, Cx. restuans has been shown to be common in both rural and urban settings [16, 17], and Cx. tarsalis is considered a primary rural WNV vector .
There have been a number of studies, at various scales, in which spatial and temporal data on climatic conditions, landscape, or demography were analyzed in relation to WNV dynamics in humans, mosquitoes, sentinels, wild birds, and horses.
Demographic patterns can influence vector and host ecology and thus potential disease distribution. Ruiz et al.  broke Chicago and Detroit census tracts into groups based on land cover, elevation, housing, and demographic characteristics. They found that tracts classified as 'Inner Suburbs' had the highest number of human WNV disease cases in both cities. Gibbs et al.  found in Georgia that medium housing density in non-mountainous areas had higher probabilities of being associated with WNV positive birds and indicated this might be due to different vector habitat preferences.
Landscape attributes have an important effect on WNV disease dynamics and ecology by influencing host and vector presence, behaviour, and interactions. Ezenwa et al.  investigated the relationships between mosquito vectors, hosts (birds) and land cover in an area of Louisiana. They found that infection rates in Culex mosquitoes were negatively correlated with wetland area and that wetland area was positively correlated with non-amplifying bird hosts. In Mississippi, stream density, road density, slope, and Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) data from satellite imagery were used along with seasonal climatic sub-models for predicting WNV disease incidence at a zip-code level. They found that 67% of human cases occurred in zip codes in the high risk category . Vegetation indices, such as NDVI, derived from remote sensing, can be useful as they reflect vegetation vigour which in turn is influenced by landscape, temperature, and precipitation patterns.
Climatic conditions can control timing and magnitude of vector populations, as well as influence host movement and behaviour. In the Red River Valley of North Dakota, Bell et al. hypothesized that climatic conditions were poor (cool) in 2004 leading to low human WNV disease incidence. They also noted that 2003 (617 human cases) and 2005 (86 human cases) were similar in terms of climatic conditions. They hypothesized that the difference in cases was due to the immunity developed in passerine birds by 2005. However, in 2007, there were 367 cases reported in North Dakota . In Wyoming, Zou et al.  used a degree day model to predict where and when the development of WNV reached a sufficient vector infectivity level. When compared to WNV disease incidence in humans, horses, and birds for 2003–2005 they predicted 91.3, 65.2, and 78.3% correctly at a county level. Landesman et al.  investigated data nationally at a county level and found that WNV disease incidence was most strongly associated with annual precipitation from the previous year. Shaman et al.  showed that WNV infection in sentinel chickens and human WNV disease incidence was associated with drought 2–6 months prior and modeled land surface wetting 0.5–1.5 months prior.
In this study, human WNV disease incidence data, at the census block group level in Iowa (2634 census block groups in Iowa with a mean population of 1111), were analyzed in relation to landscape, climatic, and entomological data to discern if unique landscape, climatic, and demographic associations with WNV exist. There have been few studies that have analyzed human WNV disease incidence data at spatial resolutions finer than the county scale, and none of these studies were conducted in rural areas of the Midwest [7, 19, 22]. Our analysis, at the scale of census block groups, allows for meaningful analysis of landscape and climatic variables. We carried out simple statistical analyses to discern important environmental associations with the occurrence of WNV disease in Iowa.
Materials and methods
Data on the date of each human WNV disease occurrence from 2002–2006 were attained at the census block group level from the Iowa Department of Public Health (IDPH). The IDPH policy for disclosure of reportable disease information was followed for the release of the human data. This policy indicates that reporting units must have a population of at least 300 before data can be released . In this case, all census block groups with WNV disease incidence had a population of at least 500. Spatial data on 2000 census block group geography, land cover (2002), stream and road networks, digital elevation model (DEM), permitted irrigation points (>= 94.75 m3/day), and animal feeding operations were acquired from the Iowa Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) . The census block group attribute data included a total population figure, which was used to calculate population density. The land cover data was produced by the IDNR from satellite imagery in 2002 and 2003 and has a resolution of 15 m. This dataset was generalized and reclassified from 17 to 9 classes (unclassified, water, wetlands, forest, grassland, agriculture/row crops, roads, commercial/industrial, residential). The 30 m resolution National Elevation Dataset DEM was used to produce a slope raster for Iowa. The topographic slope is considered, as flatter areas are more likely to foster areas of standing water important for mosquito development. Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI, 16 day composites, 250 m resolution) data from NASA's MODIS satellite were acquired for the years 2002–2005 from the University of Maryland Global Land Cover Facility (GLCF) . The NDVI data were scaled to a range of 0–250 by the GLCF for easier display purposes. Raster surfaces, at a resolution of 4 km2, of annual minimum temperature, maximum temperature, precipitation, and dewpoint temperatures were acquired from the Oregon State University PRISM website . The PRISM (Parameter-elevation Regressions on Independent Slopes Model) climate mapping system is a knowledge-based system that uses point measures of climatic data, digital elevation data and expert knowledge of complex climatic extremes to produce continuous climatic surfaces for the United States.
Data on mosquito abundance in Iowa were obtained from the Iowa-Mosquito.net website [29, 30], that houses approximately 35 years of mosquito surveillance data collected using New Jersey Light Traps from throughout Iowa. Culex mosquito species abundances were compiled from the multiple collection locations in thirteen counties in Iowa for the years 2002–2006. Mosquito collections took place at 31–33 sites per year and with beginning dates from early May to late May and ending dates ranging from mid-September to early October. A more detailed description of the trapping regime in Iowa can be found in Socaet et al. . Due to the difficulty in morphologically distinguishing adult Cx. pipiens and Cx. restuans individuals, these mosquitoes were grouped and are referred to as the Cx. pipiens group. Data on WNV infections in mosquitoes are presented based on previously unpublished data collected by the Iowa State University Medical Entomology Laboratory. From 2002–2006, multiple mosquito collection trips were made during peak vector activity periods. Mosquitoes were collected at multiple sites across the state using CO2 baited CDC and Mosquito Magnet® traps or grass infusion baited gravid traps. Mosquitoes were transported on dry ice to the Medical Entomology Laboratory at Iowa State University (ISU) to be identified and pooled for virus isolation.
Data Processing and Analysis
All human WNV disease cases from 2002–2006 in Iowa were geocoded using ESRI's ArcGIS software and a custom address locator, which included zip codes, by the IDPH. Approximately 79% of the 298 locations were geocoded successfully originally. All of the unsuccessful addresses were corrected and successfully geocoded by checking each mismatch in the recorded address and those in the address locator. The address points were then given the value of the census block group they fell in using a spatial join. The attribute table of the geocoded points was exported to a stand-alone table and all sensitive patient information was removed, so the only remaining information in the table was the week of year for each occurrence and the census block group identifier. Thus, the researchers outside of the IDPH were never given any human patient information.
All spatial processing was carried out using ArcGIS 9.2 and extensions of ArcGIS. The percentage of area falling in each individual land cover class within each census block groups was calculated using the 'Thematic Raster Summary' tool in the Hawth's Tools extension . The density of streams and roads falling in each census block group was calculated by carrying out an intersection and then dividing the length of the roads or streams in each census block group by the area of that census block group. The number of irrigation points and animal feeding operations falling in each census block group was calculated by running the 'Count Points in Polygon' tool in the Hawth's Tools extension. Only more rural (defined as a population density of less than 0.5 persons/ha) census block groups were analyzed in order to distinguish whether the presence of irrigation and animal feeding operations might be important for the occurrence of WNV disease. Zonal statistics operations were carried out to calculate the mean elevation and mean slope, as well as the mean annual minimum temperature, maximum temperature, precipitation, and dewpoint temperature for each census block group. Iowa census block groups were separated into eastern and western regions by manually splitting the state approximately in half for comparing regional differences in some climatic and landscape associations. The average NDVI score for each year (March-September) was calculated for the state of Iowa. This time period was chosen as it was thought to encompass the potential WNV development season in Iowa. In addition, the mean NDVI score (March-September) by census block group for each of the years was calculated.
A Global Moran's I spatial autocorrelation test was carried out for the WNV disease incidence rate by census block group using distance threshold bands of 0, 2.5, 5, 10, and 20 kilometers. In addition, a hot-spot analysis was carried out based on the Getis-Ord Gi* statistic for distance thresholds of 2.5, 5, 10, and 20 kilometers. Both of these analyses were carried out using ArcGIS's Spatial Statistics tools .
Statistical analyses were carried out using SPSS 14.0 for Windows. T-tests in SPSS were used to test whether mean landscape, demographic, and climatic values for census block group with and without human WNV disease incidence were significantly different. When the Levene test showed a violation of the assumption of homogeneity of variance, the 'equal variances not assumed' option is reported . For some of the analyses, including that of irrigation and animal feeding operations points, there were violations of the assumptions of normality, and thus the nonparametric Mann Whitney U test was used to test differences in distributions between census block groups with and without WNV disease.
The number of human WNV disease cases and the mean and median week of occurrence by year are shown in Table 1. For each year the greater percentage of WNV disease cases were in the western part of the state. The earliest median week of occurrence was in 2006 in week 33 and the latest was in 2002 in week 37. In eastern Iowa WNV disease cases occurred slightly later in the year (average week of occurrence = 35.22) than in western Iowa (34.93).
Cluster and Hot Spot Analysis
Tests showed that there was statistically significant (p < 0.05) spatial autocorrelation in WNV disease incidence rates at all distance thresholds tested. The results of spatial autocorrelation analysis for the different distance thresholds are as follows: distance threshold = 0 m, Moran's Index = 0.026, Z-score = 12.89; distance threshold = 2500 m, Moran's Index = 0.034, Z-score = 2.87; distance threshold = 5000 m, Moran's Index = 0.034, Z-score = 4.33; distance threshold = 10000 m, Moran's Index = 0.036, Z-score = 6.23; distance threshold = 20000 m, Moran's Index = 0.038, Z-score = 7.71. Each of the hot-spot analyses for human WNV disease rates (with differing distance thresholds) showed statistically significant hot-spots mainly in the western half of Iowa with significant cold-spots in urban areas. Figure 1 shows the results for the five km hot-spot analysis. The red areas indicate statistically significant hot-spots while the dark blue represent statistically significant cold spots for human WNV disease rates. The other threshold distances showed similar patterns with larger areas being statistically significantly hot or cold at the 20 km distance.
Demographic, landscape, and climatic analysis
There was a statistically significant difference (t-value = 5.65, df = 2633, P = 1.7E-8) in mean population density between census block groups with (N = 258, mean = 3.72, SD = 7.09) and without WNV disease incidence (N = 2377, mean = 7.41, SD = 10.2). Figure 2 shows the mean population density of census block groups with 0–3 incidences of human WNV disease from the period 2002–2006. Figure 3 illustrates the distribution of census block group centroids which had WNV disease cases overlain on a map of population density. There was not a statistically significant difference (t-value = -1.43, df = 256, P = 0.15) between eastern (mean = 2.77) and western (mean = 4.14) population densities in census block groups with WNV disease incidence.
The absolute t-values resulting from the T-tests comparing landscape variables in census block groups with or without WNV disease incidence is presented in Figure 4. Figure 5 represents the land cover of Iowa with census block groups overlain. Statistically significant higher mean stream density and proportion of agricultural areas were found in census block groups with human WNV disease incidence. Statistically significant lower mean road density and proportional area of wetlands, forests, commercial land use, and residential land use were found in census block groups with human WNV disease incidence. The Mann Whitney U test comparing the mean number of animal feeding operations and irrigation points in rural census block groups (N = 955), with and without human WNV disease incidence, showed statistically significant differences between the sample distributions indicated by the mean rank. For animal feeding operations, those census block groups with WNV disease incidence (N = 138, 161 WNV disease cases) had a higher mean rank (581.3) than those census block groups without WNV disease incidence (N = 817, mean rank = 460.55) (Z = -4.822, P = 1.42E-6). For irrigation points, those census block groups with WNV disease incidence (N = 138) had a higher mean rank (522.54) than those census block groups without WNV disease incidence (N = 817, mean rank = 470.48) (Z = -2.615, P = 0.009). There was a negative relationship at the state level between the mean NDVI and the number of human WNV disease cases (Figure 6) for the years 2002–2005. When the mean NDVI by census block groups was analyzed, there were no statistically significant differences in any of the years between those with or without human WNV disease incidence.
The test of means for climatic variables in census block groups with and without human WNV disease incidence for year of occurrence is presented in Table 2. In 2003 there was significantly (P < 0.01) less precipitation, lower mean dewpoint temperatures, and lower minimum temperatures in census block groups that had human WNV disease occurrence. In 2004 and 2005, there were significantly (P <= 0.02) lower minimum temperatures in census block groups with human WNV disease incidence. In 2006, there was significantly (P = 0.006) lower precipitation in census block groups with WNV disease incidence. The test of means for climatic variables in census block groups with and without human WNV disease incidence for preceding year is presented in Table 3. In the years 2003, 2004, and 2005 there were significantly lower precipitation, dewpoint temperatures, and minimum temperatures in the preceding year in census block groups with WNV disease incidence.
In some instances, there were differences in climatic associations with WNV disease cases in the eastern and western regions of Iowa, as presented in Table 4. In 2002, in the west, and in 2006 in the east, there were statistically significant differences between precipitation in census block groups with (more precipitation) and without WNV disease incidence, while in 2003 there was significantly less precipitation in census blocks with WNV disease incidence in the western region of the state. In each year there were lower average minimum temperatures in census block groups with WNV disease incidence than those without in the western region of the state. These differences were statistically significant in all years except 2002. In 2003 and 2006 there were statistically significantly lower dewpoint temperatures in census block groups with WNV disease incidence in the western part of the state.
In Iowa, there is a spatial shift in the distribution of key vector species in the genus Culex as measured by mosquito collections in New Jersey Light Traps (NJLT) . Throughout the state, the Cx. pipien group are the most common species collected but Cx. tarsalis proportions go up in the western part of the state (Figure 7). Table 5 shows the timing of human WNV cases and timing and total number of Cx. pipiens group and Cx. tarsalis by week as collected in NJLT traps, as well as when positive pools of these mosquito species were found from 2002–2006. The mosquitoes both had similar temporal occurrences, with the highest percentage of mosquitoes in an individual week caught in week 26. There was a slight dip in Cx. tarsalis collections in weeks 28–30, and then a rebound with approximately 33% collected from weeks 31–34. From 2002–2006 there were 57 WNV positive mosquito pools found throughout the state, out of 3240 pools tested. The Cx. pipiens group accounted for 41 of the positive pools with the rest being Cx. tarsalis (13), Cx. erraticus (2), and Aedes trivittatus (1) Out of the 13 positive WNV pools of Cx. tarsalis mosquitoes found, 12 were in the western half of the state. However, positive pools of the Cx. pipiens group were found throughout the state. Overall, 64.5% of positive WNV mosquito pools were found in the western part of the state. The majority of WNV cases (62.8%) and positive mosquito pools (Cx. tarsalis = 77%, Cx. pipiens group = 56.2%) were found in weeks 34–38. Positive Cx. pipiens group pools were found both earlier and later than Cx. tarsalis pools.
Human WNV disease incidence first occurred in significant numbers in Iowa in 2002 and peaked in 2003 with 147 cases. This is consistent with the second year of significant intrusion having the highest number of human cases. Illinois (884), Michigan (614) and Ohio (441) had the highest number of human cases in 2002, while in 2003 Colorado (2947), Nebraska (1036), and South Dakota (1039) had the highest number of human cases in the country. In each of these states, the virus was first detected in a significant amount in the previous year . There are many possible reasons for these reductions after the peak year. These reasons could include public awareness, increased mosquito abatement, and a build up of immunity in bird and mammal populations . Immune birds are considered dead-end hosts like humans . Although none of these states has matched the peak number of cases, there have been a large number of cases since 2004 .
Human cases of West Nile virus have occurred throughout Iowa, with a greater concentration in the western part of the state (Figures 1 and 5). The analysis of spatial autocorrelation for human WNV disease rates showed significant hot-spots in Western Iowa over the course of the study period and significant cool spots in some urban areas. States directly to the west of Iowa, including Nebraska (10.9% of cases, 0.6% of population in continental USA) and South Dakota (6.2% of cases, 0.26% of population), have had some of the highest WNV disease rates in the country [1, 34]. In Iowa, using the east-west split as described earlier, Eastern Iowa has 0.54% of the continental USA population with 0.36% of the WNV disease cases from 2002–2006, while Western Iowa has 0.45% of the continental USA population with 0.9% of the WNV human disease cases . This higher incidence rate and the increasing proportion of Cx. tarsalis trapped in the western half of the state suggest that the western half of Iowa exhibits vector-host ecology more similar to that in the states to the west [10, 35]. Culex tarsalis mosquitoes feed on both mammals and birds and thus are more likely to serve as a bridge vector to humans than mosquitoes of the Cx. pipiens group .
In a novel finding, it was shown that human cases of WNV disease occurred in more rural settings in Iowa. This is opposed to eastern studies which showed more urban/suburban occurrence [7, 19, 20]. Figure 2 demonstrates that census block groups with an increasing number of human WNV disease cases (zero to three cases) had progressively lower population densities, while Figure 3 also demonstrates the rural nature of cases. There have been a limited number of studies that specifically investigated population density [7, 11, 19, 20] in relation to WNV disease incidence. In Chicago and Detroit, areas classified as 'Inner Suburbs' with moderate population density had the highest percentage of WNV disease cases [7, 19]. Similarly in Georgia, moderate housing density was associated with WNV disease incidence . In Nebraska, the highest seroprevalence of WNV, estimated by blood donor data, was in the most sparsely populated part (western) of the state . In Iowa, the western half of the state has a lower population density (0.17 persons/ha) than the eastern half (0.23 persons/ha). However, the census block groups with WNV disease incidence had a lower population density (although not a statistically significant difference) in the eastern part of the state. There were 213 (71.5%) cases in the western part of the state. The nine most densely populated census block groups with WNV disease incidence are in the western part of the state. It is possible this was caused by a higher overall WNV infection rate in mosquitoes in the Western part of the state. This is supported by the fact more positive WNV mosquito pools were found in the western half (64.5%) of the state. Figure 1 demonstrates that several of the cities in Eastern Iowa show up as being cold spots for human WNV disease rates, while none of the western cities do. In Sioux City, which is along the Missouri River on the western border, there were 13 cases in densely populated census block groups. Rural census block groups around this city also had WNV disease incidence. It is possible the movement of vectors or hosts between the rural-urban interface might have led to the urban WNV disease cases. Also, the fact that in the western part of the state both Cx. pipiens group and Cx. tarsalis positive mosquito pools were found extensively, could help explain both the urban and rural human disease occurrence. It must be noted that due to logistical constraints of running a continuous collection regime, the NJLT locations are often located in or near towns or cities and thus sampling of rural areas is likely a bit under-represented. This could lead to an under representation of Cx. tarsalis mosquito populations and positive pools, as they are a very rural mosquito.
The results of the land cover and land use analysis supported the rural nature of WNV disease incidence in Iowa. The most significant difference in land cover mean proportions between census block groups with and without WNV disease was for agricultural/row crop areas (Figure 4). Figure 5 demonstrates the large number of agriculturally dominated census block groups with WNV disease occurrence. In addition, the land use indicators of permitted agricultural irrigation and animal feeding operations were associated with the census block groups with WNV disease incidence. In California, Reisen et al.  suggested that farmhouse environs provide 'islands' of elevated vegetation used by birds for nesting and by Cx. tarsalis for host-seeking and resting. This could help explain the agricultural association in Iowa also. Total crop sales were shown to be a significant independent predictor of WNV disease incidence by county in Colorado, Nebraska, Louisiana, and Pennsylvania in 2002–2003 . However, the number of irrigated acres was not a significant predictor in that study. In the Great Plains region , and in California , large populations of Cx. tarsalis were associated with irrigated areas. In 2003, the year of highest WNV disease incidence in Iowa, census block groups with WNV disease incidence had significantly less precipitation than those without. In the drier years of 2003 and 2005, a higher proportion of census block groups with WNV disease incidence were ones which contained permitted irrigation points compared to the other four years. The interaction of agricultural activity, such as irrigation and intensive animal operations in relation to mosquito abundance, and WNV disease incidence needs to be studied more thoroughly in Iowa. Census block groups having WNV disease incidence encompassed less forested areas than those without. Many heavily forested areas have low population densities. Culex tarsalis larval habitats include newly-created sunlit surface pools surrounded by grasses  and thus forested habitat likely does not support Cx. tarsalis larvae. Also, Cx. pipiens is considered an urban mosquito and thus also might not be prevalent in or near forested areas. If Cx. tarsalis is the primary vector in Iowa, then we might expect there to be higher proportion of grasslands associated with WNV disease, but there was no significant difference in grassland proportions in census block groups with and without WNV disease. Higher proportions of the built environment land cover classes (roads, commercial, residential) were associated with those census block groups without WNV disease. This implies that the urban-centric Cx. pipiens species might play a more minor role in Iowa as compared to the rural Cx. tarsalis species. Urban and suburban land use was an important predictive variable for WNV disease incidence in Georgia  and Illinois  where the more urban Cx. quinquefasciatus and Cx. pipiens are considered the primary vectors respectively. There is not a large amount of wetland area in Iowa (~0.5% of state), and it is often in quite rural areas, but it was still somewhat surprising that wetlands were shown to be less common in census block groups with WNV disease. This could be due to host-vector interactions that are not well understood. In Louisiana, Ezenwa et al.  found that WNV infection rates in Culex mosquitoes declined with increasing wetland cover. They found that the area of wetlands was significantly and negatively correlated with the passerine to non-passerine bird ratio and they theorize that the non-passerine bird species act as dilution hosts. At a state level there was a negative relationship between NDVI score and WNV disease cases as indicated in Figure 6. This is interesting, in that warmer and drier years (2003 and 2002) had more WNV disease than a cooler and wetter year (2004). Given that this was a March-September NDVI average, and for only a four year period, limited conclusions can be made.
Some interesting year-by-year associations were made between climatic data and WNV disease incidence. However, analysis of climatic data from the year of WNV disease observations did not reveal any consistent trends. In 2003, census block groups with WNV disease had significantly less precipitation, lower dewpoint and average annual minimum temperatures. These relationships were very strong in the western half of the state but reversed in the eastern part of the state indicating varying disease dynamics. In 2003, there were relatively wet conditions in May, June, and July, but then a very dry August. The mean and median week of WNV disease occurrence was at the end of August. This is opposite to the pattern described by Shaman et al. , where early season drought followed by later season rainfall led to large outbreaks. The mean annual minimum temperature was always lower in census block groups with WNV disease incidence and significantly so in 2003, 2004, and 2005. This relationship was true for all years in the western part of the state with 2003, 2004, 2005, and 2006 having significantly lower average minimum temperatures in census block groups with WNV disease incidence. This is a bit contradictory to other studies that conclude higher temperatures could potentially increase probability of WNV transmission [23, 40]. The magnitude in differences on an annual basis (e.g. approximately 0.5°C) are not huge and it is unclear in what way this would have an effect on WNV disease incidence. However, given that we considered only annual average climatic variables, it is possible that more detailed temporal data might reveal different associations. Temperatures are generally lower in the northern part of the state, which also has significant agricultural areas and animal feeding operations. The influence of temperature needs to be examined more thoroughly to help understand its effect on human WNV disease incidence in Iowa. The differences between eastern and western halves of the state suggest that different vector-host-disease dynamics have been occurring in different parts of the state. A possible difference is that drier conditions in western Iowa lead to higher levels of irrigation which in turn provides good habitat for Cx. tarsalis mosquitoes. The majority of irrigation points (~71%) were in the western part of the state. Landesman et al.  demonstrated regional difference in precipitation associations with WNV disease incidence for the United States as a whole when split into east and west using the Mississippi River as a dividing line. They point out that this is likely due to the transition to Cx. tarsalis as the primary vector in the western United States. This is supported by the fact that the proportion of Cx. tarsalis positive mosquito pools increased as WNV moved westward in 2001–2004 . Figure 7 demonstrates that in Iowa there is a transition as you move west to a greater proportion of Cx. tarsalis out of total Culex mosquitoes. Numerous studies have used degree days to explain or estimate the timing of mosquito populations and WNV disease occurrence [23, 40, 41], and this is an approach that might be used in Iowa in the future. The timing of vector abundances and WNV disease incidence needs to be studied in greater depth.
Other studies have demonstrated that climatic phenomena from the preceding year can be important for mosquito activity  and WNV disease incidence . In Iowa, in 2003, 2004, and 2005 there were significantly lower mean precipitation values, annual average dewpoint temperatures, and annual average minimum temperatures in the preceding year for census block groups with WNV disease incidence. Similar to this study, Landesman et al.  found that 2003 and 2004 WNV disease incidence was associated with lower amounts of precipitation in the preceding year. They cite the theory put forth by Chase and Knight  that disruption of food-webs in preceding years by drought can lead to large outbreaks in wetland mosquitoes the next year. In Iowa, Cx. tarsalis populations were highest in 2004 , following drought in late summer 2003, but the number of human WNV disease cases and sentinel chicken seroconversions were lowest. In addition, no WNV positive mosquito pools were found in 2004 in Iowa. Similar to this study, Landesman et al.  also found that WNV disease incidence in 2002 was associated with greater precipitation in 2001. In Iowa, those census block groups with WNV disease incidence had greater precipitation totals in 2001 but not significantly so. These findings clearly indicate a need for more detailed temporal study of climatic effects.
The dynamics of human WNV disease in Iowa show rural and agricultural association in Iowa with greater occurrence in the western part of the state. The rural nature of disease incidence, and association with agriculture in the state overall, suggests that Cx. tarsalis is the more important vector in the state. However, the inconsistency in the climatic associations over the five year study seem to indicate that there might not be consistent ecological dynamics leading to disease incidence over time and space. A future area of research should be detailed investigation of the temporal and spatial dynamics of entomological data in relation to WNV disease incidence. This research would be aided by the investigation of bird and mammal interactions with mosquito vectors. A more detailed temporal and spatial analysis of climatic and entomological data could begin to help untangle the complicated WNV disease dynamics at a more local scale in the northern Midwest.
Center for Disease Control, West Nile Virus.http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/westnile/
Ebel GD, Rochlin I, Longacker J, Kramer LD: Culex restuans (Diptera: Culicidae) relative abundance and vector competence for West Nile virus. J Med Entomol. 2005, 42 (5): 838-843. 10.1603/0022-2585(2005)042[0838:CRDCRA]2.0.CO;2.
Shaman J, Day JF, Stieglitz M: Drought-induced amplification and epidemic transmission of West Nile virus in southern Florida. J Med Entomol. 2005, 42 (2): 134-141. 10.1603/0022-2585(2005)042[0134:DAAETO]2.0.CO;2.
Allen TR, Wong DW: Exploring GIS, spatial statistics and remote sensing for risk assessment of vector-borne diseases: a West Nile virus example. Int J of Risk Assess Manage. 2006, 64 (4–6): 253-275. 10.1504/IJRAM.2006.009546.
Kilpatrick AM, Kramer LD, Jones MJ, Marra PP, Daszak P: West Nile virus epidemics in North America are driven by shifts in mosquito feeding behaviour. PLoS Biology. 2006, 4 (4): 606-610. 10.1371/journal.pbio.0040082.
Orme-Zavaleta J, Jorgensen J, Ambrosio BD, Altendorf E, Rossignol PA: Discovering spatio-temporal models of the spread of West Nile virus. Risk Analysis. 2006, 26 (2): 413-422. 10.1111/j.1539-6924.2006.00738.x.
Ruiz MO, Tedesco TJ, McTighe TJ, Austin C, Kitron U: Environmental and social determinants of human risk during a West Nile virus outbreak in the greater Chicago area, 2002. Int J Health Geogr. 2004, 3: 8-10.1186/1476-072X-3-8.
Theophilides CN, Ahearn SC, Grady S, Merlino M: Identifying West Nile virus risk area: The dynamic continuous-area space-time system. Am J Epidemiol. 2003, 157 (9): 843-854. 10.1093/aje/kwg046.
Theophilides CN, Ahearn SC, Binkowski ES, Paul WS, Gibbs K: First evidence of West Nile virus amplification and relationship to human infections. International Journal of Geographical Information Science. 2006, 20 (1): 103-115. 10.1080/13658810500286968.
Bell AJ, Brewer CM, Mickelson NJ, Garman GW, Vaughan JA: West Nile virus epizootiology, Central Red River Valley, North Dakota and Minnesota, 2002–2005. Emerg Infect Dis. 2006, 12 (8): 1245-1247.
Schweitzer BK, Kramer WL, Sambol AR, Meza JL, Hinrichs SH, Iwen PC: Geographic factors contributing to a high seroprevalence of West Nile virus-specific antibodies in humans following an epidemic. Clin Vaccine Immunol. 2006, 13 (3): 314-318. 10.1128/CVI.13.3.314-318.2006.
Kramer LD, Li J, Shi P: West Nile virus. Lancet Neural. 2007, 6: 171-181. 10.1016/S1474-4422(07)70030-3.
Granswehr BP, Lillibridge KM, Higgs S, Mason PW, Aronson JF, Campbell GA, Barrett ADT: West Nile virus: Where are we now?. Lancet Infect Dis. 2004, 4: 547-556. 10.1016/S1473-3099(04)01128-4.
Kilpatrick AM, Kramer LD, Campbell SR, Alleyne EO, Dobson AP, Daszak P: West Nile virus risk assessment and the bridge vector paradigm. Emerg Infect Dis. 2005, 11: 425-429.
Hayes EB, Komar N, Nasci RS, Montgomery SP, O'Leary DR, Campbell GL: Epidemiology and transmission dynamics of West Nile virus disease. Emerg Infect Dis. 2005, 11 (8): 1167-1173.
Turell MJ, Dohm DJ, Sardelis MR, O'Guinn ML, Andreadis TG, Blow JA: An update on the potential of North American mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae) to transmit West Nile virus. J Med Entomol. 2005, 42 (1): 57-62. 10.1603/0022-2585(2005)042[0057:AUOTPO]2.0.CO;2.
Ebel GD, Rochlin I, Longacker J, Kramer LD: Culex restuans (Diptera: Culicida) relative abundance and vector competence for West Nile virus. J Med Entomol. 2005, 42 (5): 838-843. 10.1603/0022-2585(2005)042[0838:CRDCRA]2.0.CO;2.
Epstein PR, Defilippo C: West Nile virus and drought. Global Change & Human Health. 2001, 2 (2): 2-4.
Ruiz MO, Walker ED, Foster ES, Haramis LD, Kitron UD: Association of West Nile virus illness and urban landscapes in Chicago and Detroit. Int J Health Geogr. 2007, 6: 10-10.1186/1476-072X-6-10.
Gibbs SEJ, Wimberly MC, Madden M, Masour J, Yabsley MJ, Stallnecht DE: Factors affecting the geographic distribution of West Nile virus in Georgia, USA: 2002–2004. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis. 2006, 6 (1): 73-82. 10.1089/vbz.2006.6.73.
Ezenwa VO, Milheim LE, Coffey MF, Godsey MS, King RJ, Guptill SC: Land cover variation and West Nile virus prevalence: patterns, processes, and implications for disease control. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis. 2007, 7 (2): 173-180. 10.1089/vbz.2006.0584.
Cooke WH, Grala K, Wallis RC: Avian GIS models signal human risk for West Nile virus in Mississippi. Int J Health Geogr. 2006, 5: 36-10.1186/1476-072X-5-36.
Zou L, Miller SN, Schmidtman ET: A GIS tool to estimate West Nile virus risk based on a degree-day model. Environ Monit Assess. 2007, 129: 413-420. 10.1007/s10661-006-9373-8.
Landesman WJ, Allan BF, Langerhans RB, Knight TM, Chase JM: Inter-annual associations between precipitation and human incidence of West Nile virus in the United States. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis. 2007, 7 (3): 337-343. 10.1089/vbz.2006.0590.
Policy for Disclosure of Reportable Disease Information. http://www.idph.state.ia.us/adper/common/pdf/cade/disclosure_reportable_diseases.pdf
Iowa Department of Natural Resources, Natural Resources Geographic Information Systems Library.http://www.igsb.uiowa.edu/nrgislibx/
University of Maryland, Global Land Cover Facility. http://glcf.umiacs.umd.edu/index.shtml
Oregon State University PRISM Group.http://www.prism.oregonstate.edu/
Iowa State University Department of Entomology, Medical Entomology Laboratory: Mosquito surveillance in Iowa. http://iowa-mosquito.ent.iastate.edu
Sucaet Y, Van Helmert J, Tucker B, Bartholomay L: A web-based relational database for monitoring and analyzing mosquito population dynamics. J Med Entomol.
Hawth's Analysis Tools for ArcGIS. http://www.spatialecology.com/htools/
Mitchell A: The ESRI guide to GIS analysis volume 2: Spatial measurement and statistics. 2005, ESRI Press, Redlands, California
Warner RM: Applied Statistics: From bivariate through multivariate techniques. 2008, Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publications
U.S. Census Bureau: American FactFinder.http://factfinder.census.gov/home/saff/main.html?_lang=en
Reisen W, Lothrop H, Chiles R, Madon M, Cossen C, Woods L, Husted S, Kramer V, Edman J: West Nile virus in California. Emerg Infect Dis. 2004, 10 (8): 1369-1378.
Miramontes R, Lafferty WE, Lind BK, Oberle MW: Is agricultural activity linked to the incidence of human West Nile virus?. Am J Prev Med. 2006, 30 (2): 160-163. 10.1016/j.amepre.2005.10.008.
Rapp WF: The distribution and natural history of Culex tarsalis in the Great Plains region. Proceedings of the West Central Mosquito and Vector Control Association. 10: 29-33. 6–7 February 1985
Reisen WK, Milby , Meyer RP: Population dynamics of adult Culex mosquitoes (Diptera:Culicidae) along the Kern River, Kern County, California, in 1990. J Med Entomol. 1992, 29 (3): 531-543.
Reisen W: The western encephalitis mosquito, Culex tarsalis. Wing Beats. 1993, 4 (2): 16-
Reisen WK, Fang Y, Martinez VM: Effect of temperature on the transmission of West Nile virus by Culex tarsalis (Diptera: Culicidae). J Med Entomol. 2006, 43 (2): 309-317. 10.1603/0022-2585(2006)043[0309:EOTOTT]2.0.CO;2.
Kunkel KE, Novak RJ, Lampman RL, Gu W: Modeling the impact of variable climatic factors on the crossover of Culex restuans and Culex pipiens (Diptera: Culicidae), vectors of West Nile virus in Illinois. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 74 (1): 168-173.
Chase JM, Knight TM: Drought-induced mosquito outbreaks in wetlands. Ecol Lett. 2003, 6: 1017-1024. 10.1046/j.1461-0248.2003.00533.x.
This work was supported by a NASA grant that funded the GeoInformatics, Training, Research, Education and Extension Center at the University of Northern Iowa. We would like to thank the Iowa Department of Public Health for providing the data on West Nile virus incidence at the census block group level.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
All authors were involved in conceiving the idea for the research. SB geocoded and aggregated the WNV disease incidence data to census block groups, provided interpretation of results, and contributed to the writing of the paper. JD was responsible for compiling, managing, and analyzing all of the landscape and climatic data and contributed to the writing of the paper. LB and BT provided entomological data, expertise on mosquitoes, and contributed to the writing of the paper. RS assisted in results interpretation and contributed to the writing of the paper.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
DeGroote, J.P., Sugumaran, R., Brend, S.M. et al. Landscape, demographic, entomological, and climatic associations with human disease incidence of West Nile virus in the state of Iowa, USA. Int J Health Geogr 7, 19 (2008) doi:10.1186/1476-072X-7-19
- Normalize Difference Vegetation Index
- West Nile Virus
- Dewpoint Temperature
- Census Block Group
- West Nile Virus Infection